Why did Wirral Council pay £700.43 for a private company to check when a fire alarm went off at Irby Library?
Wirral Council invoice Dante Irby Library £700.43 thumbnailWirral Council invoice Dante Wallasey Town Hall £671.33 thumbnail
Above are a couple of invoices from Dante Group to Wirral Council. Of course on the Dante theme, Wirral Council has its own version of the nine circles of hell in Dante’s Inferno.
Limbo is the circle that whistleblowers are sent to, lust has already been covered by the more tabloid leaning Wirral Leaks, gluttony (some politicians have fallen into this trap and it’s a shame unlike the House of Commons they don’t have to get up and stretch their legs when voting), greed is too massive a topic to go into in detail, anger (again too many examples of politicians losing their temper), heresy seems to be the circle of hell politicians fall into when somebody disagrees with them, thankfully Wirral Council is not in control of the Armed Forces so violence is rare, but allegations of fraud (which whistleblowers repeat until they’re blue in the face) still ring in the ears of those who have given up listening and of course the ninth circle of hell is one that’s wrapped up in the tapestry of Wirral’s politics treachery.
However back to the invoices (the thumbnails above link to more readable versions), the first is for one of the two most sensitive issues in Wirral’s politics that begin with l which is libraries (the other being Lyndale).
I explained to a colleague (not hard to work out who) that this invoice was for being called out to Irby Library because a fire alarm was beeping and asked her to guess how much is was for. As readers of this blog may already know Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service since 2012 don’t attend non domestic premises when an Automatic Fire Alarm goes off.
So on the 28th July 2014, Wirral Council asked Dante Group to attend Irby Library. According to something scribbled on the invoice it states "mess left (something undecipherable) by library staff Sat 26".
The public are being told that public sector bodies have no choice but to outsource to the private sector because it’s cheaper. Wirral has what used to be called the Community Patrol (before enforcement of littering got outsourced to Kingdom Security earlier this year and I think what’s left is now called the Corporate and Community Safety Team). Part of the role of the Community Patrol was to keep an eye on Wirral Council’s buildings and land.
If it was still dealt with in-house and if the Community Patrol took the long way round to Irby library, spent the whole day there and sent a team of three to investigate (along with meal expenses) I’m sure the costs wouldn’t never be as high as £700.43.
However that’s what Dante charged Wirral Council for the call out.
The other invoice for £671.33 is for fitting 1 x 8W emergency lighting tube and 4 emergency light fittings at Wallasey Town Hall and 4 12 volt batteries. Surprisingly (despite the parts) the invoice comes to £671.33 (less than the call out to Irby Library).
So if Wirral Council are paying out £700.43 each time the fire alarm goes off in a library, can they really honestly say the reason they have reduced library hours (which no doubt has led to more expensive invoices as it’s increased the hours each week libraries are closed) is because of lack of money?
If you click on any of the buttons below, you’ll be doing me a favour by sharing this article with other people.
SATIRE: What if the Saughall Massie fire station decision was a sports event?
SATIRE: What if the Saughall Massie fire station decision was a sports event?
Councillors on Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority (30th June 2015) voting in favour of closure of Upton and West Kirby fire stations and asking Wirral Council for the land and planning permission for a new fire station in Saughall MassieDan Stephens (Chief Fire Officer) answers questions at a public consultation meeting in Saughall Massie to discuss proposals for a new fire station (20th April 2015)Cllr Chris Blakeley addressing Wirral Council Regeneration and Environment committee about a new fire station in Saughall Massie September 2015
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Next week, we’ll be seeing another thrilling political battle between Cllr Chris “Bruiser” Blakeley (in the blue corner with a picture of a Conservative whip on his chest) and Dan “The Fireman” Stephens in the flaming red corner (and a picture of a fireman’s axe on his chest). Who will win following this encounter? This is a battle that the public think both of them can’t win.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: There’s a bit of history between these two characters isn’t there?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Yes, this whole fire station issue is part of the reason Chris Blakeley lost his job working for Esther McVey in May, but since then he’s had more time for campaigning. The kudos for stopping a new fire station in Greasby went to Esther McVey’s rival Margaret Greenwood (now an MP). The two (Cllr Blakeley and Dan Stephens) have had heated exchanges at a number of public meetings and are bitterly opposed on this sensitive political issue.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: But what happened last time?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: The Labour referee Cllr Mike Sullivan declared it a draw on points and decided to call it off for another night. No one had invited Dan Stephens along to that meeting so it would’ve been wrong to let Cllr Blakeley win under such circumstances.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: But strictly speaking Dan Stephens wasn’t the officer behind all this?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Yes that’s true. The man with the plan for this was Deputy Chief Executive Kieran Timmins (his line manager was Dan Stephens). However Kieran Timmins has been made redundant. So nobody can ask him questions. The land aspects of Mr. Timmins’ job are now under the remit of Deputy Chief Fire Officer Phil Garrigan.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: So if asked, Dan Stephens can deny all knowledge of the emails released under a Freedom of Information Act request or in fact anything to do with all this?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: His answer at an earlier public meeting was he hadn’t written the emails, then from memory a Labour councillor on the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority (who had released the emails) just claimed the Tories were just making it all up.
Although Dan Stephens would be aware of this matter, it would be Mr. Timmins/Phil Garrigan that would be involved in the details. I’m sure Phil Garrigan will brief him ahead of next week’s meeting with answers to questions that are likely to be asked and/or be there in person.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: So what does Dan want?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: He has to work within the agreed policy. The politicians directed him to ask for the land at Saughall Massie and planning permission (or at the very least he has to find somewhere to build a new fire station if the politicians want one).
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: So what does Cllr Blakeley want?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: For Dan Stephens not to get the land at Saughall Massie and planning permission and if he has to build a fire station to do it somewhere else.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Councillors on Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority did decide to go ahead and ask Wirral Council for the land at Saughall Massie and planning permission.
An interesting twist however, is that Cllr Blakeley seems to be have been stabbed in the back twice by his own side on this issue as both the Conservative government have offered Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service a grant towards the costs of a new fire station and fellow Conservative councillor Cllr Lesley Rennie voted for it too.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: So you’re saying in over 2 years and perhaps millions of words, all that’s happened is arguing, Esther McVey losing her seat and endless rounds of consultation over the £millions this could all cost?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Yes.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: And nobody thought it a good idea and value for money or sensible to just actually sit down and talk through these issues?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Officers did that, but thought councillors would just happily rubber stamp it. Large numbers of the public getting grumpy about a political decision makes politicians nervous. Nervous politicians don’t like to make unpopular decisions unless they know the facts so they delay making a decision.
However councillors on the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority seemed quite happy to have the people pay for taxis to and from public meetings, showing that a decision by a politician is only unpopular if the public actually knows about it.
SPORTS COMMENTATOR 2: So you’re saying that endless public meetings, consultations, press coverage and over 2 years of political arguments is because no consensus or compromise has been reached?
SPORTS COMMENTATOR JOHN BRACE: Yep, but it’s been great for our viewing and circulation figures isn’t it!?
If you click on any of the buttons below, you’ll be doing me a favour by sharing this article with other people.
EXCLUSIVE: What do the plans for a new fire station at Saughall Massie look like?
EXCLUSIVE: What do the plans for a new fire station at Saughall Massie look like?
Dan Stephens (Chief Fire Officer) answers questions at a public consultation meeting in Saughall Massie to discuss proposals for a new fire station (20th April 2015)
The story of the possibility of a new fire station in Saughall Massie has rumbled on to a new phase as Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service has requested pre application planning advice from Wirral Council. Pictured above is Dan Stephens in Saughall Massie trying to explain the need for a fire station earlier in the year to residents.
In the interests of openness and transparency (and if the Chair of the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority Cllr Hanratty is reading and deplores the drain on financial resources providing the information I’m about to show on this blog I might point out it was emailed to this blog I didn’t ask for it so no cost to the public purse whatsoever), I’m publishing here some documents to do with Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service’s request for pre-application planning advice.
Just before I get to the documents (I’m sure someone will eventually reveal what the advice is that Wirral Council receives in response to this) I will point out the way the project is described by Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service’s contractors is that this is all going through the formalities and this this is essentially a done deal. Although like Cllr Blakeley I will make it clear that is merely how anybody reading these documents would think and it may just be MFRS’s contractors getting ahead of themselves in documents that I think they wouldn’t assume would be published.
However a decision is yet to be made on the land and yet to be made over planning permission. So that’s the caveat I will put here as from the tone of some of the way these are written you’d guess that these decisions had already been made.
The purpose of pre-application planning advice is so that if there are any problems plans can be changed. So therefore it is possible the planning application will vary from the above.
As detailed by the Chief Fire Officer Dan Stephens during the consultation, once a planning application is submitted there will be a period of consultation before any decisions are made.
However if you have any comments, please feel free to leave a comment.
If you click on any of these buttons below, you’ll be doing me a favour by sharing this article with other people. Thanks:
VIDEO: A round-up of local Wirral and Merseyside politics by John Brace (part 2)
VIDEO: A round-up of local Wirral and Merseyside politics by John Brace (part 2)
Please accept YouTube cookies to play this video. By accepting you will be accessing content from YouTube, a service provided by an external third party.
If you accept this notice, your choice will be saved and the page will refresh.
John Brace on local Wirral and Merseyside politics (part 2)
Part 2 of this video series is shorter than part 1.
As before, this transcript of the video will include relevant links. After I recorded the video I found another bundle of papers that make up the BAM Nuttall contract on the scanner. There are also pages Wirral Council didn’t give me because of commercial confidentiality reasons. However I think you get the point that it’s a long contract!
Hello, I’m John Brace and this is the second part of my videos about local politics on Merseyside and on the Wirral.
One thing I’ll be talking about today is the Bam Nuttall contract. You may not have heard of Bam Nuttall, but they replaced Colas. If I went into the whole Colas saga and the senior officers that were suspended and paid oodles of money because Wirral Council didn’t quite get it right, well I’d probably use up all the tape on this camera.
But anyway going back to Bam Nuttall, in must have been 2014, Wirral Council signed up to a contract with them and the contract called, let’s see the Highway Services Contract. So for instance stuff to do with road works. Anything I think over a certain amount to do with traffic lights is someone else’s responsibility but I’ve scanned in the first bit of the contract which is here, see that’s the bit I’ve scanned in, but it’s an absolutely massive contract.
This is the next bit, bit not the rest of it! Then there’s this. That makes up the contract.
I have asked Wirral Council not to give me things on paper and to save the planet, not cut down so many trees and give them to me on a CD, but Wirral Council always seem to prefer paper.
Anyway the other thing I’ll be writing about in the near future is, this is some of the invoices I got during the audit for various things. For instance, this one is an invoice for £7,389.50 for the Moscow Ballet doing Giselle at the Floral Pavilion.
Now you may well say well what’s the point in getting an invoice for that? Well, the taxpayer actually subsidises the Floral Pavilion to a large amount of money.
So whereas for example Wirral Council sees closing down Lyndale School as a priority because they say they don’t have the money, they do have the money to be subsidising the tickets of rich people going to see the ballet at the Floral Pavilion. OK, I could look up the amount later.
The other thing I was going to talk about is Liverpool City Region Combined Authority. Now of course this was only set up in the recent past and has mired itself in all kinds of controversy over the devolution deal, price, prize, all that and elected Member stuff.
Anyway, what I did notice and this came as news to me, even though I report on the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority is that Knowsley Council has set up a website for the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority and they’re currently running a consultation on the things that make up the devolution deal.
Now, firstly before the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority was set up politicians quite categorically said, I’m not going to name the politician here but I’m sure people can find this out, I’ll probably find this out when I write this up on my blog.
They said the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority won’t cost any more money than the existing arrangements. Now registering a website, having a website hosted, dealing with all the stuff to do with a website does cost money! OK, the politicians will probably turn round and say, well this is from existing budgets or something, but it costs money that can’t be spent on something else.
So anyway, when I write this up on the blog, in the transcript I’ll include a link because to be honest it was news to me, it hasn’t been in a report that was submitted to the Combined Authority and as far as I’m concerned the only mention online about it is from Knowsley, whereas the Liverpool City Region Combined Authority is all the councils on Merseyside plus I think Halton and really speaking you shouldn’t just consult with the people of Knowsley, you should be consulting everybody.
So that’s a few things that I’ll be doing, let’s see today’s weather is cold, hence the jumper. When I was looking into market research as to what people want from a blog, one of the things that came up was weather forecasts. Now you’ll be glad to know that unless there’s a big demand I’m not going to start up with a map behind me and little symbols of clouds and sunshine, wind and all that because I really don’t fancy being a weather forecaster probably because people would love turning round and saying, “Well you said it would be sunny today John and now it’s raining!”.
But anyway if you really do want weather forecasts, there’s the Met Office website for that.
So that’s a summary of where I’m up to, this week there are hardly any public meetings because of the half term holidays and of course there’s Halloween at the weekend. One of the things that’s coming up of course is Bonfire Night and the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service, ok I’m sure people are probably sick of me talking about Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service.
Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service are running, in I think conjunction with Wirral Council, trying to clear up the, say for instance the bits of wood and stuff like that people put together for bonfires because Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service probably really don’t want to be going round putting out a lot of small fires on Bonfire Night.
I mean they’re not being killjoys or anything, there are Council organised fireworks displays and things like that so people can go along. I’m sure there’ll be one in Birkenhead Park this year, people can make the usual jokes about taxpayer’s money going up in smoke, that kind of thing.
But anyway, that’s what I’ll be doing today, I’ve decided to keep it short because typing up these transcripts takes a while, but if there’s anything you want to leave a comment on or you think I should write about then please get in touch.
OK, thanks for listening.
If you click on any of these buttons below, you’ll be doing me a favour by sharing this article with other people. Thanks:
EXCLUSIVE: What’s in the North West Fire and Rescue Services PFI Contract?
EXCLUSIVE: What’s in the North West Fire and Rescue Services PFI Contract?
The three boxes on the left comprise the PFI fire stations contract
During the 2014/15 audit I exercised a right as a local government elector in Merseyside to a copy of a contract that Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority has, which is a PFI contract for various fire stations on Merseyside.
It also involves Cumbria County Council and Lancashire Combined Fire Authority and is with Balfour Beatty Fire and Rescue NW Limited (but other companies and organisations are also involved).
The contract is the size of a DVD, so until a decision was made today here to increase the space for this blog I haven’t been able yet to publish it in full as it comes to many gigabytes of information. It falls within the "big data" journalism category because it is a collection of pdf files that are all multi-page images (hence the large file size).
When printed off it comes to three boxes worth of contract documentation (as pictured above). I hope to publish some of the associated invoices in the future too.
The size, complexity and length of the contract makes it difficult to believe that councillors (whether on the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority or Lancashire Combined Fire Authority or Cumbria County Council) could have possibly fully understood it or its implications before agreeing to it.
However as councillors are accountable to you the public on Merseyside, here is a list of councillors who were at the meeting that agreed it Councillors Tony Newman (Chair), Jimmy Mahon, Dave Hanratty, Sharon Sullivan, Les Byrom, Colin Strickland, Robbie Ayres, Barbara Murray, Ted Grannell, Denise Roberts, Linda Maloney, Lesley Rennie, Gerry Ellis, Martyn Barber, Steve Niblock and Eddie Clein.
The contract means Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority/Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service pay amounts to a private company over decades for its fire stations at a time when its overall budget is falling. Yes, the Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority controlled by a Labour majority decided behind closed doors to privatise a chunk of a public service (whereas considering Labour’s trade union links you’d expect Labour to do the opposite and fight to keep services in the public sector wouldn’t you?)
Ultimately it means taxpayer money from the council taxpayers on Merseyside (and money MFRA/MFRS receives from elsewhere) goes to fund the profits of a private company and the money was ultimately borrowed from foreign banks who pay any taxes on their profits abroad. So if they have to end up making cuts in the years to come to pay for the rising costs of this contract, it’s because of a decision they made in 2010 isn’t it (although let’s face it they’ll always try and blame any cuts on someone else such as the government)?
The contract details employees transferred to a private company rather than working in the public sector.
So, I’ve made an editorial decision to publish it. In the interests of openness and transparency of course!
It’s split into thirteen sections. In the interests of it making sense when you read it, I include a table of some of the parties and abbreviations used here.
Position
Parties
Abbreviation
Account Bank
Barclays Bank plc
Account Bank
Arrangers
Dexia Crédit Local Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale
Arrangers
Authorities
Cumbria County Council Lancashire Combined Fire Authority Merseyside Fire and Rescue Authority
Authorities, each an “Authority”
Construction Contractor
Mansell Construction Limited
Mansell
Building Sub-Contractor
Border Construction Limited
Border
Facility Agent
Dexia Crédit Local Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale
Facility Agent
FM Contractor
Balfour Beatty Workplace Limited
BBW
Funders
Dexia Crédit Local Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale
Funders
Funders’ Insurance Consultants
Aon Limited
Aon
Funders’ Solicitors
Tods Murray
TM
Funders’ Technical Advisers
Appleyards
Appleyards
Guarantor
Balfour Beatty plc
BBplc
Hedging Counterparties
Dexia Nord LB
Hedging Counterparties, each a “Hedging Counterparty”
Holding Company
Balfour Beatty Fire and Rescue NW Holdings Limited
HoldCo
Independent Certifier
Gleeds Management Services Limited
Independent Certifier
Intermediate Company
Balfour Beatty Fire and Rescue NW Intermediate Limited
InterCo
Model Auditor
[TBC]
Model Auditor
Parallel Loan Counterparty
Balfour Beatty Infrastructure Holdings Limited
BBIHL
Project Co’s Solicitors
Ashfords LLP
Ashfords
Project Company
Balfour Beatty Fire and Rescue NW Limited
ProjCo
Project Co’s Insurance Advisers
Jardine Lloyd Thomson Limited
JLT
Security Trustee
Dexia Management Services Limited
Security Trustee
Shareholder/Stockholder
Balfour Beatty Infrastructure Investments Limited
BBIIL
Sponsor
Balfour Beatty Capital Limited
BBCap
Consultant
Ove Arup & Partners Limited
Arup
Consultant
Blue Sky Design Services Limited
Blue Sky
Consultant
Seymour Harris Limited
Seymour Harris
So here’s the contract itself, I hope somebody out there appreciates it and finds this useful!
in-house counsel on capacity of BBIIL, BB, Mansell, BBW and BBIHL to enter into the Transaction Documents to which each is respectively a party, the due execution of those Transaction Documents and on the enforceability of the Transaction Documents. (9 pages)